Peer review

Reviewing in the Journal of Oral Research is a double-blind, expert peer review process where neither reviewers nor authors have access to each other's identities. All comments from both parties are filtered by the editorial team, who know the identities of both parties but ensure that all identifying information is removed.
Each manuscript submitted to the journal is assigned to an editor, who manages the pre-selection process based on thematic relevance to the journal. Rejected manuscripts cannot be used by either the editors or the reviewers.
Experts in the subject matter of each article under review are selected for the reviews. In the double-blind process, every article is reviewed by at least two reviewers. If the review results are inconsistent, the article is sent to additional reviewers before a final decision is made. Reviewers must notify the editors of any conflict of interest, including any inability to acknowledge the authors of a manuscript. They must treat manuscripts submitted for review confidentially and may not use the studies for their own research without properly citing the work upon publication. If reviewers wish to appoint a co-reviewer, they must first notify the editor in charge of the manuscript, who will decide whether the proposed person is suitable. Reviewers may not, under any circumstances, forward a manuscript under their consideration to others.
A review form is available for reviewers to complete. The standard review period is two weeks. If reviewers cannot meet the review deadline or do not believe they are experts in the subject matter of the manuscript, they must notify the editorial team or request reasonable adjustments to the deadline.

If reviewers have any concerns about ethical conduct in the research of the manuscript, or about ethical conduct in any other aspect of the publication, they should notify the editorial team.
Reviews are the property of the reviewers. The editorial team only consults them when making decisions to accept or reject manuscripts. The editorial team will not use reviews for its own research without obtaining explicit permission from the reviewers.